Napoleon vs Weber – Which’s the Best Option

With the barbecue season ahead, you must be pumped up about it. And we ourselves think that grilling is one of the most fun activities you can do with your family. But to make this experience pleasant and satisfactory, you will need a good gas grill. And we all know how much of a hassle it is to choose one. Especially in recent times where there are so many options.

There has been a battle across the courtyards to know which is the better brand and product. And among those brands, there have been two brands, Weber and Napoleon. And these have been strong contenders. So choosing between them has been difficult. Hence this is our take on Napoleon vs Weber, to bring to you their specific features. After which we will choose one according to our needs and requirements.

Napoleon vs Weber

In the following segment, we have brought to you parameters under which you can compare the brands. And reach a conclusion for the one you like.

Difference Between Napoleon & Weber

Napoleon
The Napoleon brand came into existence in the 1980s. So yes, they were considered as the energized newcomer. And the history of the brand tells us it was started by a couple. And this couple named Wolfgang and Ingrid Schroeter hailed from Germany. When they moved to Canada, they started their company which was named as Wolf Steel Ltd. And this steel company is the parent company of Napoleon Appliances. This Appliances company produces the grill we now love. And they have a variety of gas grills, charcoal grills and some portable grills.

Weber
The Weber Grills came into existence in the year 1952 in Chicago. And this was when George Stephen Sr. working in the metal works company of Weber invented a grill. And he made that grill out of one half of a marine buoy. With time there have been alternatives, innovations and improvements to that spaceship-like grill. Now, Weber produces around four different series of gas grills alone. And adding to that there are charcoal grills, portable grills, etc. We can see an example of its improvements in the special GS4 grilling system some its models have.

Grill Design

Napoleon
So all the Napoleon grills have a closed cart design. This hides the gas tank and gives it a tidy look. Also, a lot of grills in this brand have foldable shelves which make storage easy. And the lids are usually 2-piece which provide better heat retention. Also, the burners are connected to each other so when one blows out, it reignites itself.

Weber
Apart from the bigger models, Weber usually has open cart designs. Although it might not be visually appealing, it provides you with a lot of storage space. Also, the grills have individual control burners. And this means that you can light anyone or two of your choice. This is perfect to create an indirect cooking situation.

Performance

Napoleon
The Napoleon grills exhibit great performance. And they offer BTU higher than that of the Weber grills. Although BTUs are not inherently necessary, they help in quick heating. Also, the wavy grates of the grill heat and sear evenly and exceptionally. Also, a lot of the grills of the brand have an infrared side burner.

Weber
Weber grills will not disappoint you with their performance either. And they have a sear station in the main cooking section which gives off high heat, perfect for searing. A lot of these grills have Flavorizer bars which vaporize the droppings. And to the flavor of the meat and also to prevent flare-ups. These grills also come with the side burners.

Napoleon P500RSIBPSS-3

Why we love it:

  • This gas grill uses a liquid propane gas unit.
  • And there are stainless steel sear plates which provide a good sear.
  • Also, there is an infrared side burner which heats pretty quickly.
  • There is also an infrared rear burner for rotisserie cooking.

The Napoleon P500RSIBPSS-3 is one of the best gas grills the brand offers. And this grill falls under the category of top end grills of the brand. First, the grill has 4 stainless steel burners in the main cooking area. And these together produce about 48,000 BTUs in an hour. With that the main cooking area, it also has sear plates. These plates are layered and provide intense heat and flavor for perfect searing.

Then we have a wide cooking area. So the main cooking area is around 500 sq. inches itself. And that is big enough to contain at least 31 burgers at once! Apart from that we have the added warming area 260 sq. inches. Also, there is an 140 sq. inches infrared side burner. And the infrared technology lets it go up to higher temperatures of about 1800°F in a mere 30 seconds. Adding on to that, they also have an infrared rear burner. And it is powerful enough to do good rotisserie cooking.

Next we have the JETFIRE ignition system of the grill. And this basically starts your grill in seconds with no hassle. Even the burners are connected through channels that light off each other.

Pros
  • Wide cooking space
  • Sear plates
  • Infrared side and rear burner
  • JETFIRE ignition system
Cons
  • Heavy
  • Very expensive

This grill is perfect for those expert grillers who absolutely grilling. Although expensive they have performance which makes up for it. Also, you will love this if you love holding barbecue parties.

Weber 61006001

Why we love it:

  • This gas grill has a liquid propane unit.
  • And it also has a GS4 grilling system for an impressive grilling performance.
  • Also, it has a separate sear station. So this sear station creates a heat zone, intense enough to create sear marks on meat.
  • Then there is the side burner. And it helps you to saute vegetables or make barbeque sauce.

The Weber 61006001 is one of the best Weber grills, specifically in the Genesis II model.

As this has the GS4 special grilling system of the Genesis II models of the brand. And this GS4 implies the four primary features. So the first of these elements is the Upgraded E2i Ignitors. And these can help you turn on, adjust the heat and tune in the temperature of the entire grill. Then there is the second feature, the 3 stainless steel high-performance burners, which have great durability. And the third feature is the flavorizer bars in the grills, which add the extra flavor to your meat. Last, the fourth primary element is the grease management system of the grill. So there are channels that funnel the grease out of the grill into the dispensing tray for easy cleaning.

Next, there is a separate sear station from the gas grill. And this sear station imparts high intensity heat. So that you can easily add sear marks to your meat. Also, there is a side burner in the grill which you can use to saute vegetables and even simmer the barbeque sauce. Adding on to that, there are also the infinite control valves.

Moreover, the total cooking area is 669 sq. inches. Wherein the primary cooking area of 513sq. inches in which you can fit almost 20 burgers at once. And an extra 216 sq. inches warming space area for the buns. Lastly, there are the 7mm stainless steel cooking grates. And these give a great heat distribution and retention and durability. Besides that, it is also iGrill 3 compatible. And you can probe the meat by using your smartphone.

Pros
  • GS4 grilling system
  • Sear station.
  • Huge cooking space
  • iGrill 3 compatible
Cons
  • Very heavy
  • Hard to assemble

This gas grill will be a significant addition to your household. But it gives you a top-notch barbecue grill performance. So the price is actually worth it. As there is a huge cooking space on the grill, it will be perfect to host parties.

Our recommendations

We also have recommendations for you from each brand for different categories.

Napoleon

These are some recommendations from Napoleon.

Weber

Further, we have the recommendations from Weber

Above two are our favourites for portable grills of the brand.

Read More

Conclusion

So our discussion on Napoleon vs Weber ends. And we hope that your dilemmas regarding the two have quieted down a bit. We know it’s difficult to choose from the outstanding qualities these products have to offer. So we wish you best of luck.

For more information on gas grills, check our article on the best gas grills under $1000.

Visit our website Cookinggearlab for more insight on kitchen and cooking gadgets,

Please add "Disqus Shortname" in Customize > Post Settings > Disqus Shortname to enable disqus or remove '#' to disable comment section